at Financial Technnology Year
Please contact them if you have any questions.
Features in Model Validation Software
for Risk Management
Tools that independently verify and validate the mathematical and financial models used in pension fund management, ensuring accuracy and appropriate use of actuarial and investment models.
We ask vendors to mark their product against our feature list. It is not available for all products and in some cases we have derived data from publicly available sources. The list of features follows. Vendors can add a further 10 key features of their own.
Accuracy and Validation Processes
Evaluates the tools and methodologies employed to verify the correctness and appropriateness of pension fund risk models.
- Assumption Documentation
- Ensures all model assumptions are documented and validated.
- Backtesting Framework
- Includes automated routines for comparing model predictions vs actual historical results.
- Benchmark Comparisons
- Ability to compare model outputs against industry benchmarks and standards.
- Custom Validation Procedures
- Allows user-defined tests and validation scripts to be integrated.
- Error Detection Rate
- Number/percentage of material model logic, coding or data errors detected by the tool.
- Hypothesis Testing
- Automates statistical hypothesis testing for model robustness.
- Model Calibration Checks
- Verifies calibration of model input parameters.
- Parameter Validation
- Assures validity and ranges of key model parameters.
- Replication Capability
- Ability to independently reproduce model results using input data and model code.
- Sensitivity Analysis Tools
- Software provides functionality to test model output sensitivity to input changes.
- Validation Frequency
- How often models can be automatically or manually re-validated.
Auditability and Reporting
Addresses tracking, documentation, and transparency features necessary for audit, compliance, and stakeholder reporting.
- Automated Exception Tracking
- Logs and alerts where models fail validation criteria.
- Automated Report Generation
- Can automatically produce validation reports in multiple formats (PDF, Excel, HTML).
- Change Log Frequency
- Tracks frequency of model changes between validation cycles.
- Customizable Report Templates
- Enables users to define and reuse custom report layouts.
- Dashboard Overview
- Visual dashboards summarizing validation status and issues across models.
- Data Lineage Capture
- Records where and how input data was sourced and transformed.
- Export to Regulator Formats
- Exports results and reports in formats acceptable to regulators.
- Findings Severity Rating
- Ability to classify and rate severity/impact of validation findings.
- Model Version Tracking
- Keeps a detailed version history of models tested and validated.
- Stakeholder Access Control
- Granular permissions to allow auditors and regulators selective report access.
- Validation Audit Trails
- Complete logs of validation steps, findings, and actions taken.
Cost and Licensing Flexibility
Examines transparency, flexibility, and scalability of software pricing models and contracts.
- Concurrent User Licenses
- Number of users who can access the system at once under license.
- Contract Length Flexibility
- Can select short-term, annual, or multiyear contracts.
- Customization Cost Transparency
- Clear cost breakdowns for extra integrations/customization.
- Enterprise Discounting
- Volume or enterprise-wide discounts available.
- Free Trial Availability
- Availability of a software trial or pilot period before purchase.
- Modular Licensing
- License individual modules/features as needed.
- Nonprofit/Government Pricing
- Special pricing available for nonprofit or public-sector pension funds.
- Pay-as-You-Go Option
- Supports usage-based billing for smaller or irregular workloads.
- Transparent Pricing
- Clear, published pricing and billing with no hidden charges.
- Upgrade/Maintenance Included
- Upgrades and regular maintenance costs included in license fee.
Governance and Documentation
Ensures sound model risk governance processes, proper documentation and workflow oversight.
- Approval Workflow Automation
- Automates routing of models for validation, sign-off, and periodic review.
- Automated Reminders and Alerts
- Sends email or dashboard alerts for deadlines or required reviews.
- Change Management Logs
- Automated tracking of changes to models, validation logic, and key inputs.
- Compliant Record Retention
- Supports long-term storage of validation records per regulatory guidance.
- Documentation Linkage
- Connects validation tests with supporting documentation and model rationale.
- Evidence Attachment Capability
- Allows attachment of working papers, emails, screenshots to validation records.
- Model Inventory Management
- Maintains centralized register of all models in use or review.
- Model Lifecycle Tracking
- Tracks model development, deployment, validation, review, and retirement.
- Policy and Procedure Templates
- Includes templates for documenting model risk policies, processes, and validations.
- Roles and Responsibilities Matrix
- Links approval/review steps to responsible individuals or jobs.
Innovation and Futureproofing
Assesses emerging technology support, advanced analytics, and vendor commitment to future model risk standards.
- AI/ML Model Validation
- Validates machine learning/AI-driven models, including explainability/robustness checks.
- Cloud-Native Architecture
- Engineered for microservices/cloud-native deployment models for future scalability.
- Continuous Integration (CI) Support
- Provides APIs/tools for CI pipelines and automated model risk management.
- Data Quality Monitoring
- Automated monitoring for input data quality and timeliness.
- Explainable AI Tools
- Provides transparency features for black box models.
- Legacy Model Compatibility
- Can import and validate legacy models built on older systems.
- Open Standards Support
- Supports open-source data/model standards (e.g., ONNX, Predictive Model Markup Language).
- Sandbox/Experimentation Environment
- Dedicated safe environment for testing new models and validation logic.
- Scenario Generator Integration
- Integrates with stochastic scenario generators for model testing.
- Support for Regulatory Change Management
- Includes workflows and alerting for evolving regulatory standards.
Integration and Compatibility
Measures interoperability with pension fund IT environments, data sources, and risk management systems.
- API Integration
- Provides APIs for integrating validation tools with model risk management systems, data warehouses, and reporting tools.
- Batch Processing Capability
- Supports bulk validation processing runs for multiple models or scenarios.
- Cloud Deployment Options
- Available as cloud-hosted/SaaS as well as on-premises.
- Compatibility with Risk Engines
- Integrates with major risk analytics platforms (e.g., BlackRock Aladdin, MSCI Barra).
- Direct Data Import
- Ability to directly import data from common sources (databases, CSV, actuarial software, etc).
- Open Model Interface
- Accepts externally coded models (e.g., Python, R, SAS, Excel/VBA).
- Plug-in Architecture
- Allows user extensions or connectors for bespoke data/model integration.
- Real-Time Data Sync
- Can receive and process real-time data updates from external sources.
- Single Sign-On (SSO) Support
- Integrates with enterprise SSO/LDAP for user authentication.
- Supported Input Formats
- Number of natively supported input file/data types.
Model Coverage
Assesses the breadth and depth of model types, asset classes, and risk factors the software can validate within pension fund management.
- Actuarial Model Validation
- Capability to validate actuarial models for liabilities, mortality/longevity, and other pension-specific risk factors.
- Asset Class Support
- Ability to validate models for a wide variety of asset classes including equities, fixed income, real estate, private equity, infrastructure, and alternatives.
- Cash Flow Models
- Supports validation of cash flow projection models.
- Deterministic Model Support
- Supports validation of deterministic models alongside stochastic models.
- Economic Assumptions Validation
- Checks the reasonableness and consistency of macroeconomic and market assumptions in models.
- Hybrid Model Support
- Ability to handle and validate hybrid (e.g., deterministic/stochastic mixed) models.
- Investment Model Validation
- Verification and independent validation of investment and asset allocation models.
- Model Interdependency Analysis
- Checks the proper integration and interaction of multiple models (e.g., asset-liability modeling).
- Regulatory Compliance Models
- Supports checking that models adhere to regulatory standards (e.g., Solvency II, IFRS, local pension regulations).
- Scenario Analysis Coverage
- Verifies models across stress scenarios and forecast situations.
- Statistical Model Types Supported
- Number of statistical models (e.g., regression, time series, machine learning) the system can validate.
- Stochastic Model Support
- Evaluates the appropriateness and calibration of stochastic simulation models.
Performance and Scalability
Examines system speed, ability to handle large model/data volumes, and concurrent users.
- Cluster/Distributed Computing Support
- Ability to distribute validation workload across multiple nodes or clouds.
- Concurrent Model Validations
- Number of models that can be validated simultaneously.
- Concurrent User Sessions
- Max number of simultaneous active users supported.
- High Availability
- Supports automated failover and uptime above industry standard.
- Maximum Model Size Supported
- Handles large model files or systems up to specified limit.
- Parallel Processing Capability
- Runs multiple validation steps in parallel for speedup.
- Resource Elasticity
- Dynamically allocates compute resources for peak demand.
- Response Time
- Average time for interactive model validation tasks.
- Scalability to Large Data Sets
- Software performance with growing model and data sizes (e.g., stress-tested at +TB scale).
- Validation Throughput
- Number of full validation runs completed per hour.
Security and Data Privacy
Addresses data protection, user access control, and compliance with privacy regulations.
- Audit Log Tamper Detection
- Detects and alerts any unauthorized modifications to audit logs.
- Data Encryption at Rest
- Encrypts stored input data, models, and validation results.
- Data Encryption in Transit
- Uses encryption for data transmitted between systems and users.
- GDPR/CCPA Compliance
- Supports compliance with global/regional data privacy laws.
- Incident Response Procedures
- Documented and automated workflows for data breaches or security incidents.
- Multi-Factor Authentication
- Enforces multi-step verification for sensitive operations.
- Role-Based Access Control
- Granular control over who can view/modify/validate models and access reports.
- Secure Data Erasure
- Provides secure deletion of sensitive data after use.
- Time-Limited Access Tokens
- Allows issuing temporary credentials for third-party integrations.
- User Activity Monitoring
- Monitors and reports on all user login and activity events.
Usability and User Experience
Evaluates intuitiveness, ease of use, and customizability of the software interface and workflow.
- Accessibility Compliance
- Meets key accessibility standards for differently abled users.
- Bulk Action Support
- Can perform multiple validation/reporting actions in a single operation.
- Guided Validation Workflows
- Built-in guided processes to streamline validation tasks.
- Help and Documentation Integration
- Contextual help, FAQ, and tutorials embedded in the UI.
- Intuitive User Interface
- Clear and organized navigation with contextual help.
- Mobile Access
- Available interface optimized for mobile/tablet.
- Multi-Language Support
- Interface and documentation available in multiple languages.
- Training Mode
- Provides guided training environments for new users.
- User Customization Options
- Ability to customize dashboards, views, and notifications.
- Visualization Tools
- Provides interactive charts and visual summaries of validation results.
Vendor Support and SLAs
Quality, responsiveness, and customization/future-proofing of vendor support, upgrades, and commitments.
- 24x7 Technical Support
- Support/helpdesk available round the clock.
- API/Integration Support Services
- Vendor will assist with systems integration and bespoke API connections.
- Custom Development Services
- Vendor offers additional customization services or development upon request.
- Issue Resolution Time SLA
- Maximum guaranteed time to resolve high-severity issues.
- Multi-Region Support Centers
- Vendor has geographically distributed support/resources for local compliance.
- Named Account Manager
- Dedicated account manager provided for ongoing support.
- Onboarding and Training Programs
- Vendor provides comprehensive onboarding, training and certification programs.
- Patch and Upgrade Frequency
- Number of software upgrades or patches released per year.
- Service Uptime Commitment
- Guaranteed system uptime per year.
- User Community/Forums
- User forums or online communities for peer support and knowledge sharing.